General Membership Monthly Meeting Minutes 02/18/2012
The Learning Garden, Venice High School
Attendance: The meeting was attended by approximately 45 people, including approximately 20 first-time attendees. Quorum was present
PROPOSED AGENDA
- breeding project – Burbank paste tomato for Seeds of Change
- keynote presentation: Albert Chang – Report from the Organic Seed Growers Conference
- announcements
PROCEEDINGS
At 2:30 pm, the Seed Library of Los Angeles (hereafter referred to as “SLOLA”) general membership monthly Meeting was Called to Order by Chair David King, presiding. He presented and explained the SLOLA Mission Statement, as is customary practice at each meeting. The meeting was filmed by Marc Ryan.
KEYNOTE
Speaker: Albert Chang – Report from the Organic Seed Growers Conference
Albert, Chair of the Best Practices Committee, presented a sequential account of what he learned at the 6th annual Organic Seed Growers Conference in Port Townsend, WA over the weekend of January 20-21, 2012.
The conference’s keynote speaker was Dr. William Tracy from the Department of Agronomy at the University of Washington. Dr. Tracy focused on the diversity of plant life created by the processes of natural selection, and how human plant breeding amounts to directed selection from among a variable population of genes available in any plant population. Sometimes, the results of plant breeding experiments can often be unexpected. One example is the increase of corn yields due to breeding plants with different leaf angles, which allowed closer planting of corn in fields. Because of this, plant breeding is intimately tied with the success of organic agriculture in seeking methods to increase yields.
He also outlined the current state of land grant universities, which were established 150 years ago under the Morrill Act. It was such institutional program which carried out a majority of plant breeding experiments in the 20th century, however declining enrollment, lower funding, and restrictive germplasm laws have led to a drastic reduction in the past 30 years. Coupled with this are plant patent laws, which last for 17 years, and allow corporations and individuals to obtain plant utility licenses. This has led to a decrease in the biodiversity of crop varieties, and restricts people from planting certain varieties or using them as a basis for breeding new varieties without paying licensing fees, which causes increased monoculture and abandoned crop varieties. Thus, the plant breeding industry finds itself in a dire state, even when plant breeders are capable of positively affecting communities with locally adapted crops which can create niche markets and help the environment. He closed by posing a question to the audience: how to get land grant universities to focus on organic seed production – either via legislative pressure or via increased grower input?
Albert recapped the next few workshops he attended which covered basic seed saving techniques, and also outlined the difference between two types of legal breed protection: PVP (plant variety protection) patents, which last 17 years, or Plant Utility Patents, which are they type that companies like Monsanto have been busy obtaining.
Albert showed those in attendance at the meeting a photo of Matthew Dillon from Organic Seedd Alliance and Seed Matters, who has been instrumental in obtaining a $1,000,000 doantion from Clif Bar Family Foundation toward the establishment of seed banks/libraries, fellowships, and community seed toolkits. He identified Matthew as a key player who SLOLA should hope to connect with further in the future.
The next day of the conference featured a case study-based talk on Managing Isolation Distances in Organic Seed Production by John Navazio of Washington State University, and another talk on Food Regimes and Food Movements presented by Dr. Eric Holt-Gimenez of Food First, Oakland. In this talk, it was shared that over 91% of cropland is planted with just five crops: cotton, wheat, rice, corn, and potatoes. This has led to a situation in which food is too expensive. Even while the amount of food produced per capita has increased 12% since 1990, there has been a corresponding 9% rise in the global undernourished population. Dr. Holt-Gimenez criticized the roles of the Green Revolution, subsidies and tariffs, and an overreliance on trade agreements like NAFTA.
In his mind, the current food situation is caused by a Corporate Food Regime, which is based on petrochemicals, global monopolies, and GMOs. This creates a revolving cycle of policy liberalization followed by periods of devastating bust. People and farmers need to reassert their sovereign right to produce and consume food as a social right. This can create a return to sustainable farming practices.
One other important lesson that Albert learned was presented by Dr. Paul Simon of the University of Wisconsin, Jim Myers of Oregon State University, and Walter Goldstein of the Mandaaman Institute. This lesson was that the domestication of plants and animals was one of the most important human achievements. First, humans domesticated crops, and then crops domesticated humans.
Albert concluded his report with a recap and photos of the weekend’s seed swap, showing images of the various people in the seed growing industry who attended. He obtained a seed donation from Theresa Allen at Seeds of Change, which was passed to David King for inclusion in the library. She also sent him with a call for people to grow the seeds and report their experiences
MEETING ITEMS
Chair: David King
David encouraged people who have ideas for the future of SLOLA to submit them to a committee chair or officer. Soon SLOLA will start opening branches across the county to increase availability of seeds to people who want them! Potential branches include East LA, Pasadena, and the Valley.
He also announced that for future meetings a PA system would be set up so that people may better hear speakers during meetings.
To determine where members have heard about SLOLA, he asked those attending for the first time about where they had heard of the meeting. Responses included the SLOLA Facebook page, directly from David, via the LA Times, permaculture groups, and the GreenGirlLA blog.
Vice Chair: Lucinda Zimmerman
(absent)
Treasurer: Julie Mann
Julie announced the updated treasury balance of $3,226.02 and an increase of 34 new members since the last meeting. The only costs were associated with PayPal costs from new membership processing.
Secretary: Kathryn Brown
Kathryn announced that meeting minutes from 01.14.12 meeting were posted online for review.
Best Practices: Albert Chang
Albert announced that the new library space will open soon with a new inventory system designed to speed checkout.
Database: Linda Preuss
Linda announced that the database is up and running. She asked for interested volunteers to find her after the meeting or contact her at database@slola.org if they would like to help further develop the database or to update inventory. Updated inventory sheets will be distributed to members during meetings to facilitate checkout procedures and will at some future date be included in membership mailings announcing meetings.
Membership: Tim Smith
Tim reminded those attending the meeting that lifetime membership was only $10 and that inventory sheets and check-in/checkout sheets were being circulated around the meeting. He reported that membership now stands at about 310 members, and encouraged anyone wishing to join to visit him at the membership table after the meeting’s conclusion.
Web/Outreach: Kathryn Brown
Kathryn announced the creation of a new events calendar on the website and put out a call for volunteers to contribute events for the calendar. She also asked for membership input as to community groups which may be useful for outreach.
Volunteer/Library: Patty Kestin
Patty announced that current members will be receiving a survey of their volunteer skills. In addition, all new signing members are asked to note what skills and interests they have so that volunteer assessments can be made. All volunteers should contact her if they would like to participate in particular areas of the organization. In addition, there will be a workday to remodel the library and update the database. Contact her for details or to volunteer.
Also, seed checkout will be conducted in the shade house following the meeting.
NEW BUSINESS
Tomato Distribution: David King
David introduced the featured seed of the month, the San Marzano tomato from Baker Creek Heirloom Seeds, 40 packs of which were donated by Marilyn Adams at LabelGMOs.org for distribution to members in connection with their upcoming campaign to obtain a CA ballot initiative to label GMOs in food. All the seed packets were distributed.
He also announced the beginning of a SLOLA plant breeding experiment in connection with Theresa Allen at Seeds of Change. They supplied several packets of Burbank Paste tomatoes, which are no longer offered by Seeds of Change, because over the years, the size of the tomatoes has diminished. Therefore, SLOLA members who wish to participate are asked to grow out these tomatoes and select seeds from the largest tomatoes so that over several seasons the size of this variety may be increased again to commercial viability. Members who wish to grow this variety were given packets with 6 seeds each, and there were approximately 30 takers for this project. He briefly explained the process for successfully growing tomatoes to seed. There is little need to employ isolation methods with this project.
OTHER BUSINESS / ANNOUNCEMENTS
A LabelGMOs.org petition will be available for signing after the meeting at the membership table.
Mark of occupyVenice.org announced the completion of a Learning Garden workday by people affiliated with that org and encouraged people to check out the work being done by Occupy Venice.
A question was raised regarding accepting seed donations. Yes, such donations are encouraged, and can be taken to the librarians on staff in the library after the meeting.
NEXT MEETING
The next general SLOLA membership meeting will be held:
Location: The Learning Garden, Venice High School
Date: March 17, 2012
Time: 2:30 pm
CONCLUSION
Motion to adjourn the meeting was made and seconded, and meeting was adjourned at 4:00pm by David King, Chair. The seed library opened following the meeting for member checkouts.
Respectfully submitted by Kathryn Brown.